Skip to content
Chapter 2 · Verse 66
🪈 Krishna speaks
Gond-style painting of a sleepless boy watching a spinning top wobble and fall, illustrating Krishna's teaching that without discipline there is no wisdom, no meditation, and no peace.

नास्ति बुद्धिरयुक्तस्य न चायुक्तस्य भावना। न चाभावयतः शान्तिरशान्तस्य कुतः सुखम्॥

nāsti buddhirayuktasya na cāyuktasya bhāvanā | na cābhāvayataḥ śāntiraśāntasya kutaḥ sukham ||

Word by Word 11 words
na not

not, no

अस्ति
as to be, to exist

there is, exists

बुद्धिः
budh to awaken, to understand

intellect, wisdom, discernment

अयुक्तस्य
a not yuj to yoke, to discipline

of the undisciplined one, the unsteady person

ca and

and

भावना
bhū to become, to be ana continuous action

right feeling, contemplation, meditation

अभावयतः
a not bhū to be, to cultivate

of the unmeditative one, of one who does not cultivate contemplation

शान्तिः
śam to be calm, to be at peace

peace, tranquility

अशान्तस्य
a not śam to be calm

of the peaceless one

कुतः
kutas from where, how

from where, how can there be

सुखम्
su good kha space, axle-hole

happiness, comfort, ease

There is no wisdom for the undisciplined, no meditation for the unsteady, no peace for the unmeditative — and for the peaceless, how can there be happiness?

कथा

The Chain of Four

An original story

Kamala wanted to dance the way fire wants to rise.

She was eleven, with feet that moved before her mind gave permission, and she had been learning Bharatanatyam from Revathi Amma in a small hall behind the Brihadeeswarar Temple in Thanjavur, where the gopuram rose so high it seemed to lean against the sky. The hall's stone floor had been worn smooth by centuries of dancing feet. Kamala's were just the latest.

But Kamala had a problem with discipline.

She came late to practice — not always, but often enough that Revathi Amma's eyebrows would rise when the door opened. She forgot to practice the adavus at home. She started her aramandi — the deep half-sitting position that is the foundation of Bharatanatyam — with energy, but within minutes her knees would straighten and her mind would drift to the samosa stall across the street.

One evening, after a practice so scattered that even the nattuvangam beats of the mridangam player could not hold Kamala's feet in place, Revathi Amma asked her to stay.

The other students filed out. The hall emptied. The evening light came through the high windows in long gold bars, illuminating the dust that the dancing had stirred up.

Revathi Amma did not scold her. She sat on the stone floor — cross-legged, straight-backed, with the stillness of the Shiva Nataraja statue behind her — and drew four circles in the dust with her finger.

"Discipline," she said, pointing to the first circle. "Without it, your body does not obey. Your aramandi collapses. Your feet arrive late. You cannot hold the form."

She pointed to the second circle. "Wisdom. This is what grows when the body becomes still enough to learn. The meaning behind the mudra, the story inside the abhinaya. Without discipline, you never reach it."

The third circle. "Meditation. Not sitting with your eyes closed — that is only one kind. The meditation of dance is when the mudra and the meaning and the music become one thing, and you disappear into them. Without wisdom, you cannot enter it."

The fourth circle. "Peace. The stillness that lives inside the movement. The centre of the spinning wheel that does not spin. Without meditation, you will never find it."

Revathi Amma looked at Kamala. "And without peace — tell me, child — where will happiness live? In the samosa stall? In the lateness? In the mind that cannot hold still for the length of one taal cycle?"

Kamala looked at the four circles in the dust. Each one needed the one before it. Remove the first and the whole chain went dark, like pulling a plug from a string of festival lights.

"Tomorrow," Revathi Amma said, rising, "come on time. Not for me. For the first circle."

Kamala walked home through the temple streets of Thanjavur, past the bronze shops and the sweet stalls and the Cauvery glinting in the last light, and her feet — which had been restless all evening — were, for once, still.

चिन्तनम्

When your thoughts are spinning at bedtime, what is one thing that helps you slow them down? Does it work every time, or only sometimes?